Could the Astros’ Isaac Paredes Be on the Move to a Surprising New Team? The latest trade buzz might just shake up the MLB landscape in ways you never expected.
The Boston Red Sox’s recent acquisition of 3B Caleb Durbin has left many fans underwhelmed, but more importantly, it effectively removes Boston from the Astros’ list of potential trade partners. But here’s where it gets interesting: Could this move inadvertently open the door for another team to step in? And this is the part most people miss—the Milwaukee Brewers might just be that team.
With the Brewers now in need of a third baseman and seeking to add more power to their lineup, Isaac Paredes could be the perfect fit. Paredes is under team control for the next two seasons, and his contract is already set, which aligns with the Brewers’ cost-conscious approach. Here’s the kicker: The Brewers’ current tax payroll sits at just over $127 million, according to Spotrac, which is $16.5 million less than their 2025 payroll. This means absorbing Paredes’ contract is well within their spending threshold.
Potential Trade Scenario:
Astros send: 3B Isaac Paredes
Brewers send: CF Garrett Mitchell, LHP J.D. Thompson
In this deal, the Astros would acquire Garrett Mitchell, a left-handed hitting center fielder with exceptional defensive skills. Mitchell ranks in the 89th percentile for arm strength (90 MPH) and the 87th percentile for sprint speed (29 ft/sec). While he struggled at the plate last season due to injuries, his 2024 performance—8 HR, 21 RBI, 11 SB, .255 AVG, .342 OBP, and .812 OPS—showcases his potential. And this is the part most people miss: Mitchell’s power against right-handed pitching is exactly what the Astros need to balance their lineup, which is currently dominated by right-handed hitters.
Adding Mitchell would also allow the Astros to ease Cam Smith into a backup CF role while continuing his strong defensive play in right field. Meanwhile, J.D. Thompson, a 22-year-old left-handed pitching prospect, brings a fastball that tops out at 95 MPH and a repertoire that includes a sweeper, curve, and changeup. With further development, he could become a solid mid-rotation starter.
For the Brewers, Paredes would provide the right-handed power they desperately need at third base. American Family Field, their home park, is particularly friendly to right-handed pull hitters, meaning Paredes could see a significant boost in his power numbers. But here’s where it gets controversial: Is trading away Mitchell and Thompson too high a price for the Brewers, or is Paredes the missing piece they need to contend?
For the Astros, this trade works on multiple levels:
- It clears the infield logjam.
- It adds a left-handed hitting outfielder.
- It reduces payroll by nearly $8 million.
- It brings in a promising left-handed pitching prospect.
Now, here’s the question we’re all thinking: Is this trade a win-win for both teams, or are there hidden risks we’re not considering? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below—this is one discussion you won’t want to miss!
See More:
- Astros Hot Stove
- Houston Astros Analysis
- Houston Astros Discussion
- Houston Astros News
- Houston Astros Roster
- Houston Astros Rumors
